Cyber Security Series
How can we defend democracy in the digital age? And how can we ensure that military technology, strategies, and procurement planning stay in sync with the accelerating pace of technological innovation? These were among the pressing questions raised by senior leaders from politics, the business and tech communities, academia, the military, and the intelligence sector at the MSC Cyber Security Summit 2018 on May 29. The high-level decision-makers and experts present included the President of Estonia, Kersti Kaljulaid, the Estonian Ministers of Foreign Affairs and of Defence, Sven Mikser and Jüri Luik, the NATO Assistant Secretary General for Emerging Security Challenges, Antonio Missiroli, the Norwegian Armed Forces Chief of Cyber Defence, General Inge Kampenes, and the Inspector of the Cyber and Information Space Command of the German Armed Forces, General Ludwig Leinhos.
It was the sixth Cyber Security Summit the MSC hosted jointly with Deutsche Telekom, with this year's summit also benefitting from cooperation with the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Estonia and the NATO Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence (CCDCOE). The full-day program of the summit featured three on-the-record panel discussions, as well as a number of smaller roundtable sessions under Chatham House Rules.
Cyber Security and the MSC
Besides its annual flagship conference in Munich, the Munich Security Conference (MSC) Foundation regularly organizes high-profile events around the world. These events include summits and roundtables dedicated to a particular thematic focus like European Defence, Energy Security, Cyber Security, and Health Security.
For its cyber security activities, the MSC is partnering with the EastWest Institute, Deutsche Telekom, Google, and Microsoft to offer the best possible platforms for an open exchange of ideas and opinions.
Cyber Security Summits
The MSC's Cyber Security Summits address an audience of up to 150 senior representatives from government, the private sector, and NGOs, while also retaining the MSC's trademark atmosphere of open exchange and frank debates in an exclusive setting. Cyber Security Summits have been held at Deutsche Telekom Headquarters in Bonn in 2012, 2013, and 2014, in Silicon Valley in 2016, and most recently in Tel Aviv in June 2017. The next Cyber Security Summit will take place on May 29, 2018 in Tallinn, Estonia.
Cyber Security Roundtables
The MSC's Cyber Security Roundtables are small off-the-record gatherings of not more than 40 participants taking place throughout the year in major cities around the world.
Past Cyber Security Roundtables have been held in New York, Abu Dhabi, Berlin, on the sidelines of the Munich Security Conference 2016, in Addis Ababa, and in Beijing. Most recently, Roundtables have taken place during the Munich Security Conference 2017 and at the margins of the MSC Core Group meeting in Washington in May 2017. The next Cyber Security Roundtable will convene on November 6 in Brussels.
Other Activities on Cyber Security
In addition, cyber security plays an important role at most MSC activities. During the annual conference in Munich, it has regularly taken center stage at panel discussions and numerous side events, and also plays an important role at events such as the European Defence Summit.
Roundtable on Technology & Security in Munich (2018)
For the first time, the MSC dedicated a roundtable at the annual flagship conference to the growing challenges that artificial intelligence poses to the arena of international security. The event was attended by leading representatives from militaries, governments, the think tank community, and the private sector.
Participants agreed that a race to the top in artificial intelligence was already underway. Managing the risks of artificial intelligence and its intersections with current technologies, such as nuclear weapons, was considered a crucial undertaking for the near future. The discussion also revolved around the wider topic of cyber space, where traditional notions of deterrence and proportionality are less and less adequate. There was broad agreement that discussions of cyber space’s role should no longer be held in isolation, but in the context of concrete conflict scenarios.
Roundtable on Cyber Security in Munich (2018)
At the sidelines of the Munich Security Conference 2018, the MSC organized a Cyber Security Roundtable, titled "Mutually Assured Disruption – Deterrence in the Age of Cyber Geopolitics." Partnering with the NATO Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence (CCDCOE) and the EastWest Institute, the event brought together a group of selected participants from non-governmental organizations, governments, private companies, international organizations as well as the military.
During the roundtable, participants discussed possible threats of state-sponsored cyberattacks and to which extent institutional responses could increase stability in cyberspace. Participants highlighted the role that the United Nations and other multilateral fora could play in the process of adopting norms of behavior for states. Subsequently, the debates at the roundtable focused on the moral and legal responsibility of technology companies in the creation of cyber infrastructure and tools, including offensive cyber weapons.
What are the current shortcomings of the EU legislative agenda and policy debate on cybersecurity? Is Europe sufficiently prepared to deal with cyber aggression by third countries and which instruments should Europe develop to respond to large-scale cyber-attacks? How can the political deadlock in the cyber norms process between Western "like-minded" states and Russia/China be overcome? And how is technology impacting geopolitics and how is geopolitics impacting technology? These were some of the crucial questions that were discussed at the MSC Roundtable on Cybersecurity on November 6, 2017 in Brussels.
The fifth MSC Cyber Security Summit (CSS) was co-hosted with Deutsche Telekom in Tel Aviv on June 28, 2017, bringing the MSC Cyber Security Series to one of the most dynamic IT hubs in the world. On occasion of Israel's Cyber Week 2017, the MSC partnered with the National Cyber Directorate at the Israeli Prime Minister's Office and the Blavatnik Interdisciplinary Cyber Research Center at Tel Aviv University. By placing our debates alongside cutting-edge discussions on the IT and digital industries at Cyber Week, the summit attempted to bridge the often bemoaned disconnect between tech practitioners and policy-makers. The summit's 120 participants included senior representatives from politics, business, academia, the military, and the intelligence sector.
Topics of discussion included the cyber dimension of Grand Strategies in international relations, the challenge digital technologies pose to democratic processes, the vulnerability of critical infrastructure, and the efficacy of cyber norms. The public agenda of the summit can be found here. The most important points made during the debates are summarized in our conference report. You can also get an impression of the summit from the photos and videos in our media library.
Cyber Security Summit in Silicon Valley (2016)
On September 19 and 20, 2016, the Munich Security Conference and Deutsche Telekom organized the fourth Cyber Security Summit in Palo Alto, California. It was hosted by the Center for International Security and Cooperation at Stanford University's Freeman Spogli Institute for International Studies. Among the roughly 100 participants were representatives from US and EU authorities, the cyber security coordinators of several European states, numerous business leaders, as well as security experts from various Silicon Valley companies.
Cyber Security Summit 2014
The third Cyber Security Summit took place on November 3, 2014 in Bonn. More than 180 senior guests from politics, the private sector, the intelligence community, and NGO leaders discussed the state of play and potential steps ahead concerning recent developments in cyber and information warfare, data protection, and expectations and responsibilities of ICT companies.
Cyber Security Summit 2013
On November 11, 2013, around 130 top managers of major German corporations, leading politicians, and experts from the EU and Germany came together for the second Cyber Security Summit. The conference focused on the topics of espionage and sabotage and the regulatory frameworks at the national and international level. In working groups, participants discussed cyber security as a factor for investment and innovation, defining common areas for action and providing ideas for a networked digital defense.
Cyber Security Summit 2012
The first Cyber Security Summit took place on September 12, 2012, in Bonn. For the first time, the Munich Security Conference together with the Deutsche Telekom brought together high-ranking experts to discuss challenges of cyber security. The final communiqué of the first Cyber Security Summit (in German) is available for download here.